icon Skip to content
Trigger the fancybox

Eye Coal

Adornment

  • women-owned
  • herbalist-formulated
  • cruelty-free
Charcoal Black Eyeliner & Cream Eyeshadow
Charcoal Black Eyeliner & Cream Eyeshadow

Eye Coal

Adornment

  • women-owned
  • herbalist-formulated
  • cruelty-free
Purchase Options
Select the frequency:
  • Save 15% on every subscription
  • Flexible delivery
  • Cancel / pause anytime

Description

Somewhere between an eyeliner and an eyeshadow lives Eye Coal.

Black Eye Coal is a rich charcoal black cream pigment that glides on as a soft liner or blends into a smoky shadow. Made with cosmetic-grade mineral pigments and nourishing botanical ingredients, it delivers buildable color with a creamy texture that wears beautifully from subtle definition to bold drama.

Apply with your fingertip for an effortless smoky eye or use a fine brush for crisp wings, graphic lines, and defined waterlines.

Best for:
Classic black eyeliner
Smoky eyes
Waterline definition
Bold or subtle eye looks
Anyone who loves timeless black liner
0.15 fl oz

*Note on new fill lines! Our new fill line reflects the size we have always had labeled on our adornments. Historically, we went above and beyond this fill but found that the product was going past its prime and suggested use of 6 months after opening. For both quality and safety, we have made this change. Please reach out if you have any additional questions!

Ritual

 Use a clean fingertip to press Black Eye Coal along the lash line and blend outward for a soft smoky effect.

For more precision, apply with a thin eyeliner brush. Black can be worn as a liner, blended across the lid as a cream shadow, or layered for extra depth and intensity.

Shelf Life

Lasts 6 months. Store in a cool and dry place. Our products are organic and freshly made skin food. We do not use toxins that make things last forever.

Ingredients

Sunflower Oil (Helianthus annuus)*, Oxide, Kaolin Clay, Arrowroot Powder (Maranta arundinacea)*, Cetyl Alcohol, Beeswax (Cera alba), Elderberry Extract (Sambucus)

*Organic
^Ethically & Safely Wildcrafted

Black Eye Coal is made without synthetic fragrance, parabens, petroleum-derived ingredients, artificial dyes, silicone, or plastic-based glitter.

Shop The Look

Reviews

Description
Somewhere between an eyeliner and an eyeshadow lives Eye Coal.

Black Eye Coal is a rich charcoal black cream pigment that glides on as a soft liner or blends into a smoky shadow. Made with cosmetic-grade mineral pigments and nourishing botanical ingredients, it delivers buildable color with a creamy texture that wears beautifully from subtle definition to bold drama.

Apply with your fingertip for an effortless smoky eye or use a fine brush for crisp wings, graphic lines, and defined waterlines.

Best for:
Classic black eyeliner
Smoky eyes
Waterline definition
Bold or subtle eye looks
Anyone who loves timeless black liner
Ritual
Use a clean fingertip to press Black Eye Coal along the lash line and blend outward for a soft smoky effect.

For more precision, apply with a thin eyeliner brush. Black can be worn as a liner, blended across the lid as a cream shadow, or layered for extra depth and intensity.
Color Therapy
Details
Our Black Eye Coal was inspired by a beloved teacher in India, who applies charcoal made from burned puja and ghee around the eyes. That tradition inspired this rich charcoal shade, reminiscent of lava rock, charcoal, and polished tourmaline.Its creamy texture sits somewhere between a liner and a shadow, making it easy to smudge, blend, or build into dramatic definition.

Good for:
Classic black eyeliner
Smoky eyes
Cream eyeshadow
Waterline application
Dramatic evening looks
Everyday definition

Not ideal for:
Waterproof makeup looks
Liquid-style graphic liner
Those looking for an ultra-matte powder finish
Specs: 0.15 fl oz

*Note on new fill lines! Our new fill line reflects the size we have always had labeled on our adornments. Historically, we went above and beyond this fill but found that the product was going past its prime and suggested use of 6 months after opening. For both quality and safety, we have made this change. Please reach out if you have any additional questions!
Shelf Life:
Lasts 6 months. Store in a cool and dry place. Our products are organic and freshly made skin food. We do not use toxins that make things last forever.
Our Recipe
Sunflower Oil (Helianthus annuus)*, Oxide, Kaolin Clay, Arrowroot Powder (Maranta arundinacea)*, Cetyl Alcohol, Beeswax (Cera alba), Elderberry Extract (Sambucus)

*Organic
^Ethically & Safely Wildcrafted

Black Eye Coal is made without synthetic fragrance, parabens, petroleum-derived ingredients, artificial dyes, silicone, or plastic-based glitter.
Packaging is an Ingredient
Glass Jar
With Tinplate Plastisol-Lined Top
Once empty: Clean and rinse jar, separate lid, and place both parts in the recycling bin or take to your local recycling facility.

Label
Printed on 100% Post-consumer Waste material with compostable ink. They can be left on containers when placed into recycling.

Carton
Made from Post-consumer Waste Paper
Once Empty: Break down the carton and place it in the recycling bin or take it to your local recycling facility.
FAQ
Is Black Eye Coal an eyeliner or an eyeshadow?
Both. Black Eye Coal is designed to work as a cream eyeliner or a blendable cream eyeshadow depending on how you apply it.
Can I apply Black Eye Coal with my finger?
Yes. Fingers create a beautifully soft, smoky finish. For sharper lines, use a clean angled or eyeliner brush.
Can I use Black Eye Coal on my waterline?
Yes. Black Eye Coal can be applied to both the upper and lower waterline using a clean fingertip or fine brush.
Can I use Black Eye Coal on my eyebrows?
While Black Eye Coal can be used on brows, most people find Earth Eye Coal creates a softer, more natural brow look. If you have very dark hair or prefer a bold brow, Black Eye Coal can work beautifully with a small angled brush.
How do I remove Black Eye Coal?
Black Eye Coal removes easily with a gentle makeup remover, cleansing oil, coconut oil, or our All Cream.
Is Black Eye Coal waterproof?
No. Black Eye Coal is designed to be blendable rather than waterproof. Once it sets, it wears beautifully, but it can still be removed with oil-based cleansers.
Will it dry out before I finish the jar?
Because Eye Coal is made with fresh botanical ingredients rather than heavy synthetic preservatives, the texture may slowly firm over time. Always use clean fingers or brushes and keep the lid tightly closed to maximize freshness.
The Coven
We call ourselves the ‘Coven’ as a shorthand of the space where our team gathers to intentionally conceive of, organize, create and ship out herbal bod care. We do everything under one roof, and ‘magical self manufacturing operation of botanical body care potions’ is a mouthful.
Who We Are
Herbalists, writers, proud fur baby parents, artists, musicians, gardeners, students. We self manufacture in our small town in the Sierra Foothills to invest in our incredible community of multidimensional beings.